Lesson 4 of 7 - optimize your relationships

Prenuptial Cohabiting Can
 Spoil Marriage

By Jeanna Bryner
via Yahoo online news - 7/14/09

The Web address of this article is https://sfhelp.org/relate/news/cohabit.htm

Updated  02-20-2015

        Clicking underlined links here will open a new window. Other links will open  an informational popup, so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or allow popups from this nonprofit Web site. If your playback device doesn't support Javascript, the popups may not display. Follow underlined links after finishing this article to avoid getting lost. .

      This research summary suggests that the reason/s for couples moving in together before marriage may promote later breakups. .See my comments after the report. - Peter Gerlach, MSW,

+ + +

Couples who shack up before tying the knot are more likely to get divorced than their counterparts who don't move in together until marriage, a new study suggests.

Upwards of 70 percent of U.S. couples are cohabiting these days before marrying, the researchers estimate. The study, published in the February issue of the Journal of Family Psychology, indicates that such move-ins might not be wise.

And it's not because you start to get on one another's nerves. Rather, the researchers figure the shared abode could lead to marriage for all the wrong reasons.

"We think that some couples who move in together without a clear commitment to marriage may wind up sliding into marriage partly because they are already cohabiting," said lead researcher Galena Rhoades of the University of Denver.

Couples might also be nudged into nuptials because of a joint lease or shared ownership of Fido - along with other practicalities.

Relationship dynamics

Rhoades and her colleagues did telephone surveys with more than 1,000 married men and women between the ages of 18 and 34, who had been married 10 years or fewer. Survey questions included measures of relationship satisfaction, dedication to one another, level of negative communication and sexual satisfaction. To measure the potential of a couple to divorce, participants were asked "Have you or your spouse ever seriously suggested the idea of divorce?"

Overall, about 40 percent of participants reported they didn't live together before marriage, 43 percent did so before engagement, and about 16 percent cohabited only after getting engaged.

Those who moved in with a mate before engagement or marriage reported significantly lower quality marriages and a greater potential for split-ups than other couples. For instance, about 19 percent of those who cohabited before getting engaged had ever suggested divorce compared with just 12 percent of those who only moved in together after getting engaged and 10 percent of participants who did not cohabit prior to the wedding bells.

"We think there might be a subset of people who live together before they got engaged who might have decided to get married really based on other things in their relationship," Rhoades told LiveScience, "because they were already living together and less because they really wanted and had decided they wanted a future together."

So a joint lease or shared ownership of pets could nudge the nuptials for these folks, more than a lifelong commitment to one another.

Why move in?

While this research suggests cohabitation in itself can result in lousier marriages, the initial reasons for moving in together could impact the relationship quality.

In another study led by Rhoades published in the February issue of the Journal of Family Issues, cohabiting couples ranked a list of reasons for cohabitation. More than 60 percent of participants ranked spending more time together as the number-one reason for moving in, followed by nearly 19 percent who put "it made most sense financially" at the top of their list, and 14 percent ranking "I wanted to test out our relationship before marriage" highest.

Those who listed "testing" as the primary move-in reason were more likely than others to score high on measures of negative communication, such as, "My partner criticizes or belittles my opinions, feelings, or desires." Such testers also had lower confidence in the quality and stability of their relationships.

Overall, those who want to test the commitment might want to think again, according to the February study.

"Cohabiting to test a relationship turns out to be associated with the most problems in relationships," Rhoades said. "Perhaps if a person is feeling a need to test the relationship, he or she already knows some important information about how a relationship may go over time."

Copyright 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.


      This research summary was available to millions of people thru LiveScience.com and Yahoo News. Casual readers risk coming away with a false conclusion: "...cohabitation itself can result in lousier marriages." Not true.

      This article avoids the complex subjects of what "marriage" is, and what makes a "good marriage." The main value of this report (as I see it) is to illustrate how shallow thinking and superficial journalism can significantly mislead the reading public.

      Imagine a typical cohabiting couple's reaction to reading this research summary. My guess is it would cause some anxiety ("does this mean we're going to break up?"). It may cause more discerning couples to clarify why they choose to live together, and whether to commit to each other or not.

      The unremarked American divorce epidemic suggests most typical couples aren't discerning. They choose the wrong people to commit to, for the wrong reasons, at the wrong time. self-improvement Lessons 1-4  in this non-profit Web site offer resources to help couples make three wise courtship choices together.

      For more perspective, see these articles on marriage, divorce, and family mergers, and this related research summary on unmarried couples.    

- Peter K. Gerlach, MSW

  This article was very helpful  somewhat helpful  not helpful    

Share/Bookmark  Prior page  /  Lesson 4  /  Print page 


site intro  /  course outline  /  site search  /  definitions  /  chat contact