Lesson 7 of 7 - evolve a high-nurturance stepfamily
	Q&A About Stepfamilies What You Need to Know By Peter K. Gerlach, MSW Member NSRC Experts Council

  

• site intro > course outline > Lesson 7 tasks or links, site search, chat, or prior page > here

The Web address of this article is https://sfhelp.org/sf/qa.htm

Updated 06-05-2015

      Clicking underlined links here will open a new window. Other links will open  an informational popup, so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or allow popups from this nonprofit Web site. If your playback device doesn't support Javascript, the popups may not display. Follow underlined links after finishing this article to avoid getting lost.

      This is one of a series of lesson-7 articles on how to evolve a high-nurturance stepfamily. The "/" in re/marriage and re/divorce notes that it may be a stepparent's first union. "Co-parents" means both bioparents, or any of the three or more stepparents and bioparents co-managing a multi-home nuclear stepfamily.

      Based on my clinical research since 1979 with over 1,000 typical stepfamily members, This article offers questions about stepfamilies that average adults and their supporters need to explore and discuss.

      These Q&A items assume you're familiar with..

the intro to this nonprofit Website, and the premises underlying it. self-improvement Lessons 1 thru 6, these Q&A items about relationships, this example of a real stepfamily

      If you're a media professional, please see this.

  Questions you should ask about stepfamilies

1)  What is a stepfamily? What is a nuclear stepfamily?

2)  Is it OK to call a stepfamily a "blended family" or some other non-step label?

3)  How are typical stepfamilies like (intact) biofamilies?

4)  How are they different, and what do these differences mean?

5)  What are the benefits of being in a (high-nurturance) stepfamily?

6)  Are typical stepfamilies "as good as" intact biofamilies?

7)  (a) Why is it vital that members accept their identity as a stepfamily (vs. "We're just a family") and learn what that identity usually means; and (b) how can you tell if someone has accepted their step-identity?

8)  What are the most common myths about typical stepfamilies, and  what are the realities?

9)  Who belongs to a multi-home stepfamily? 

10)  If a divorcing parent re/marries, is their ex mate a member of their stepfamily?

11)  What are the most common stepfamily stressors and problems?

12)  What should we know about stepfamilies before we commit to forming or joining one?

13)  Are there different kinds of stepfamilies?

14)  Do most clergy, counselors, lawyers, and educators get adequate stepfamily training? How can we pick an effective stepfamily coach or counselor?

15)  What are values and loyalty conflicts and relationship triangles, and why are they important in typical stepfamilies?

16)  How can we recognize credible, practical stepfamily advice and publications, and what stepfamily books and other resources do you recommend?

17)  Are we still a stepfamily if...

• the youngest stepchild moves out? Yes.

• a stepchild's other bioparent is dead? Yes..

• I legally adopt my partner's child/ren? Yes..

• both remarried partners have prior children? Yes..

• a stepparent and their mate conceive a child together? Yes..

• all our prior kids are adults? Yes..

• some "authority" disputes these answers? Yes.

18)  What's different about roles and relationships in typical divorcing families and stepfamilies, compared to those in intact (bio)families?

19)  What is effective co-parenting after parental separation and divorce?

20)  How can conflicted divorcing parents improve their relationship?

21)  Should typical stepfamily members expect to love each other like (healthy) genetic relatives do? NO.

22)  What are the most common problems between adults in average divorcing families and stepfamilies, and what causes them?

23)  Why are many stepfamily relationships significantly stressful, and what can reduce such stress?

24)  How long does it take for typical stepfamily relatives to bond, stabilize, and feel like a family?

25)  I'm less interested in nurturing a certain stepfamily relationship than the other person is, and I feel guilty. What are my options?

26)  Is it a good idea for stepparents to adopt their stepchild? See this for perspective.

27)  What do typical new stepfamily members need to know to evolve a high-nurturance stepfamily over time?

28)  What if some relatives disapprove of the re/marriage and/or a new stepparent?

29)  What if a divorced parent's relatives want to keep an active relationship with his or her ex mate and/or their relatives?

30)  What problems do typical co-grandparents face, and what are their options? See this article.

31) Where can stepfamily adults get support? See this article.

32)  After re/marriage, is there a best way to plan family events? Yes

33)  How can new step-relatives handle significant racial, religious, or ethnic differences?

34)  I'm confused about names and titles in our new stepfamily. Are there any norms or guidelines?  Yes.

35)  What can stepfamily relatives do if they feel significant favoritisms among their stepfamily's adults and kids? See this article

      Pause and reflect - how many typical courting couples do you think would seriously research questions like these before making long-term stepfamily commitments? My professional experience since 1979 is - "under 5%."

      For more stepfamily perspective, also see these Q&A articles on...

courtship	marriage	ex mates
stepparenting	stepkids	stepsiblings.

 If you don't see your question here, please ask!

Answers

Q1)  What is a stepfamily? What is a nuclear stepfamily?

      A stepfamily is an ancient kind of normal social group in which one adult mate nurtures one or more kids their partner conceived with another person. The titles for their reciprocal family roles are stepparent and stepchild. The prefix "step-" comes to us over 1,000 years from the middle-English root stoep-, which meant "not related by blood (genes)."

      Orphans and stepparents were common in (and long before) William the Conqueror's days because of disease, ignorance, war, and unprotected intercourse. Stepfamilies have probably been the global norm for thousands of years until advances in medicine, law, sanitation, and political stability in the last several centuries.

      From ancestral and social unawareness, modern stepfamilies are often viewed as nontraditional and inferior. Because of this undeserved bias, many co-parents, kin, and stepkids deny their stepfamily identity, causing unrealistic expectations and significant stress.

top

Q2)  Is it OK to call a stepfamily a "blended family" or some other label?

      Technically, a blended or "complex" stepfamily is one in which each mate has kids from a prior union, so each partner is a bioparent and a stepparent.

      Many people associate the prefix "step-" with inferior, weird, abnormal, failure, second best, and unnatural. (Do you?) Our unaware media encourages this. To avoid these uncomfortable associations, lay and professional people use "family" adjectives like bi-nuclear, co-, blended, bonus, reconstituted, non-traditional, special, reconstructed, second, rem(arried), and serial instead of "step-.".

      Using such "feel-good" labels risks...

using unrealistic (biofamily) expectations about stepfamily norms, roles, dynamics, and relationships;

making up to three unwise courtship commitment-decisions; and...

spreading the toxic delusion that stepfamilies are abnormal, inferior, and deficient compared to intact biofamilies.

These factors combine to promote legal and psychological re/divorce and passing on psychological wounds to the next generation. I have repeatedly observed that avoiding "step-" titles and labels usually indicates significant psychological wounds and harmful unawareness.

top

Q3)  How are typical stepfamilies like intact biofamilies?

      Just as males and females are the same in some ways (e.g. they both have ears) and different in others, typical stepfamilies and intact biofamilies have similarities and over 70 differences. If stepfamily adults and supporters only focus on the similarities and don't learn the differences and what they mean, they risk using inappropriate biofamily-based role and relationship expectations as they try to merge their several multi-generational biofamilies.

      So co-parents need to separate these similarities from the many structural and dynamic differences (Q4 below) about multi-home stepfamilies, learn and apply realistic expectations, and educate their kids, kin, and supporters. self-improvement Lesson 7 can help you do this.

top

Q4)  How are stepfamilies different, and what do these differences mean?

      Typical multi-home stepfamilies differ from average intact biofamilies in two major ways. Can you name them?

• Stepfamily systems are "built" differently than biofamilies in 35 ways (!) These structural differences and the unique way stepfamilies begin (after death or divorce) also cause...

• extra developmental stages and up to 36 unique adjustment-tasks. Can you name at least 10 of them?

        Adults who are aware of most of these ~70 differences and what they mean are most likely to share realistic expectations and teach them to others. Lesson 7 in this Web site focuses on learning and discussing these similarities and differences, what it means to be in a stepfamily, and what their adults and kids can expect as they slowly merge and stabilize their several biofamilies over four or more years after committing and cohabiting.

      Consider investing in the unique guidebook Stepfamily Courtship (Xlibris.com, 2002) for practical information and suggestions before or after exchanging vows. It contains much of the content in Lesson 7 here.

top 

Q6)  Are typical stepfamilies "as good as" intact biofamilies?

      What is a good apple tree? A good armadillo? A good family? Premise: families exist to fill the needs of their members, so "good" (functional, high-nurturance) families fill most members' needs well enough, most of the time.

      From this view, "Are stepfamilies as good as biofamilies?" really asks "Can typical stepfamilies fill their members' needs as well as typical intact biofamilies?" There is no inherent structural or social reason they can't. However, because of widespread unawareness of five hazards and what to do about them, many stepfamily kids and adults don't get their normal developmental and unique adjustment needs met well enough.

      Perspective: if it's true that over half of U.S. first-marriages divorce psychologically or legally, most biofamilies aren't "as good as" high-nurturance ("functional") families of any sort. The point is - motivated adults in any family can learn to identify and fill their own and their kids' needs well enough, often enough. Typical divorcing-family and stepfamily adults have more to learn (Q12 below) and more tasks to master to accomplish that vital goal, over many years. 

top

Q9)  Who belongs to a multi-home stepfamily? 

       How would you describe what belonging to a group means? Not belonging? At the least, belonging means an adult or child feels known, accepted, and (ideally) valued for who they are, and what they bring to other group members.

      Belonging can mean that other family members...

• have formed some degree of genuine bond with you (weak > strong), and merit you bonding with them to some degree. You and they may or may not like each other, and members...

• expect certain attitudes, values (like loyalty and respect), and behaviors from you, and...

• are dutifully or genuinely concerned about your feelings, needs, opinions, and welfare, compared to non-members.

      Other family members spontaneously want to include you in normal rituals and special events, and miss you when you're absent more than non-members. Belonging can also mean feeling part of, pride in, and loyalty to, an ancestral chain, clan, and culture - e.g. "I have Scotch, German, and Iroquois roots."

      From this perspective, any adult or child who doesn't feel the things above - or doesn't want them - is not a stepfamily member. Most members of newly-merging biofamilies have never met, and have few shared experiences from which to form genuine (vs. polite) new bonds. 

      Typical stepfamily members can feel obliged to include each other in celebrations and gatherings when they really don't know or care much about each other. If chronic, such pretenses (a) breed anxieties, distrusts, guilts, avoidances, confusion, and superficial relationships; and (b) suggest wounded, unaware adults and a low-nurturance family.

      This can cause "pseudo" membership, where people fake caring and closeness from politeness, duty, and wanting to appear "normal" and "sociable" (like happy biofamily members). Kids and ex mates who resent or fear the losses (broken bonds) that a re/marriage and/or cohabiting and merger may bring can reject membership (inclusion) even if it's genuinely offered.

      Stepfamily members vary in their degrees of caring and interest in each other, so "membership" is subjective. It changes over time, and ranges from "none" to "full" depending on who's judging, what they need, and what criteria they use.

      The need to belong (be noticed, accepted, valued, and supported) is primal, with roots in infancy. Lesson 7 will help adults accept and understand their stepfamily identity, and agree on who belongs.

top

Q10)  If a divorced parent re/marries, is their ex mate a member of their stepfamily?

      YES! Some stepfamily mates, relatives, and supporters deny that ex mate/s are full members of their multi-home stepfamily (exclusion). Conversely, some ex mates imply or declare they don't want to be members of the new stepfamily (rejection).

      Family-membership exclusion and rejection usually cause significant stress for all adults and kids, long-term. Like it or not, divorcing bioparents are bound together genetically, legally, historically, financially, and psychologically, until the last of their common children dies - so yes, ex mates are full stepfamily members.

      Stepfamily-membership exclusion and/or rejection is strong evidence of psychological wounding + ineffective communication + adult stepfamily unawareness + (often) incomplete grief. Exclusion and rejection usually confuse (stress) most minor and grown stepkids, who automatically include both bioparents in "my family" no matter what anyone says. Both views promote escalating loyalty conflicts, divisive relationship triangles, and many secondary problems.

        See this article for more perspective on stepfamily membership.

top

Q12)  What should we know about stepfamilies before we commit to forming or joining one?

      To make three wise decisions on whether to form or join a complex, risky stepfamily or not, typical courting co-parents need to work patiently together for many months at these seven crucial self-improvement Lessons.  At the least, they need to discuss these common courtship danger signs.

top

Q13)  Are there different kinds of stepfamilies?

      From one view, there is only one kind of stepfamily: a group of related adults and kids building relationships, filling needs, and helping each other grow through normal life phases.

      Considering combinations of adults' prior parenthood + children's ages, genders, and custody arrangements + prior divorces or mate-deaths + other factors, there are over 100 structural types of normal stepfamily. This guarantees that people in a stepfamily will never meet another one composed like theirs. This can cause a sense of alienation and aloneness that intact-biofamily members seldom feel. This helps to explain why many people ignore, minimize, or reject their stepfamily identity.

top

Q14)  Do most clergy, counselors, lawyers, and educators get adequate stepfamily training? How can we pick an effective stepfamily counselor?

      From researching and working professionally with stepfamilies since 1979, my impression is that schools that train clergy, attorneys, teachers, judges, coaches or counselors, therapists, doctors, social and welfare workers, mediators, and law-enforcement professionals aren't aware yet of the vital need for basic stepfamily training. I suspect related professional standards and licensing organizations aren't either.

      To my knowledge, there are now no U.S. organizations that provide comprehensive stepfamily training for human-service professionals. The National Stepfamily Resource Center (NSRC) offers periodic partial training. Reality check: ask any family professionals you know if they received any formal education in stepfamily needs, dynamics, norms, and stressors.

       When typical stepfamily adults need factual, empathic professional advice, they often don't know how to evaluate service providers. If they do, they can't find any who know basics like these. This contributes to our unremarked U.S. re/divorce epidemic.

         For specific suggestions on how to pick an effective stepfamily counselor or therapist, see this article.

top

Q15)  What are values and loyalty conflicts and relationship triangles, and why are they important in typical stepfamilies?

      These three related stressors are inevitable in and between typical divorcing-family and stepfamily homes:

• values conflicts occur when two or more people hold different preferences or faith-based beliefs (you eat red meat, I'm a vegetarian), They range from minor to intense.

• loyalty conflicts  occur when an adult or child feels s/he must choose between supporting one of two or more people s/he values; and...

• relationship triangles  occur when three or more people unconsciously adopt combative Persecutor, Victim, and Rescuer relationship roles.

      If a bioparent must choose whether to fill their child's needs or their new partner's needs, is there a "right" choice? Are stepparents wrong to expect their mate to put them first in such conflicts which have no acceptable compromises?

      Can a typical re/marriage last if a stepparent feels "second" (or less) too often? In my experience, confusion and conflict over these inevitable stepfamily questions are a leading surface reason for our unremarked re/divorce epidemic.

      The real issues causing typical loyalty conflicts and relationship triangles are unseen psychological wounds + ineffective communication + stepfamily unawareness + (sometimes) incomplete grief and excessive post-divorce guilts. All of these an be reduced with education, personal awareness and healing, and patient hard work - perhaps with informed lay and professional support.

        See this article for more perspective and solutions.

top

Q18)  What's different about roles and relationships in typical divorcing families and stepfamilies, compared to those in intact biofamilies?

      All family relationships exist to fill each person's primary needs. Average divorcing families and stepfamilies have unique structures + adjustment tasks + special needs to be filled + new sources of confusion, discomfort, and conflict + major environmental differences from typical intact biofamilies.

      Typical intact biofamilies have up to 15 traditional roles (mother, son, uncle, cousin, grandmother, etc.) Typical stepfamilies have these and up to 15 alien new roles. There is no social consensus yet on how to "do" these step-roles and associated relationships "right," so each stepfamily must invent their own rules and guidelines by trial and error.

      Typical stepfamilies are composed of three or more multi-generational biofamilies. They have many more members and relationships than average intact biofamilies, which promotes confusion, frustrations, unrealistic expectations, and concurrent membership and loyalty conflicts and relationship triangles that high-nurturance biofamilies don't experience.

      These many differences combine to create significant stress for unaware adults and kids as they  merge their biofamily systems and stabilize their new family system over many years. So it's vital that adults in typical divorcing families and stepfamilies study, discuss, and apply these self-improvement Lessons - ideally starting in courtship.

      See this and this for 70 specific biofamily-stepfamily differences and related tasks.

top 

Q20)  How can conflicted divorcing parents improve their relationship?

      Options...

• work to keep your true Selves in charge of your personality (i.e. work at Lesson 1). This often requires hitting true (vs. pseudo) bottom - usually in midlife or later;

• adopt a patient, long-term outlook, rather than looking for quick fixes;

• clarify your personal priorities, affirm your mutual rights as worthy persons, and use these wise guidelines in all your relationships;

• tailor these premises about resolving relationship problems to fit your situation;

• assess which relationship problems you want to reduce, click "More detail," and discuss appropriate options;

• see if any of these communication options help;

• Use qualified professional help as needed along the way;

• Affirm and enjoy your progress together! If you have trouble following this framework, suspect that well-meaning false selves are impeding you.

      If this looks like a lot of work - it is. Are your kids' worth your best efforts at these steps?

        For more perspective, see these basics.

top

Q21) Should stepfamily members (expect to) love each other like genetic relatives do?

      Most stepfamily experts advise "Strive for mutual respect and friendship over some years, not love."

      For perspective, think of one or more adults and kids you love, and try to describe what that is. Try describing the difference between loving, liking, respecting, needing, and admiring out loud as though to a pre-teen. For more perspective, think of several adults or kids you may like or care about, but don't love. What causes the difference?

      Relations among average biofamily adults and kids range between strong bonding and deep love > friendship  > indifference (no bonding), numbness, or codependence > disrespect and dislike > "hate." Feeling mutual love is probably not our national norm, tho many people mindlessly say "Of course I love my family members."

      A more practical question is "Should typical stepfamily kids and adults (expect to) feel the same degree of interest in, caring for, loyalty to, and bonding, as healthy genetic relatives do? My opinion is "No," because typical stepfamilies differ from intact biofamilies in over 70 structural and developmental ways!

      Progressing from "we're strangers" to "acquaintances" to "friends" to "bonded, loving family members" takes...

• years of shared experiences, and...

• a lucky combination of personality traits, values, and common interests ("good chemistry").

 Do you agree? Think of several important relationships in your life and reality-test this idea.

      Adults and kids who (a) reject their stepfamily identity or (b) accept it but don't know stepfamily realities, risk heartache, hurt, and frustration by expecting to love each other like people in (ideal) biofamilies. In most cases, this is unlikely. There are exceptions with stepparents who have known stepkids since infancy and/or who have "good chemistry" by chance.

      As survivors of childhood neglect and pain from divorce or the death of a loved one, many steppeople long for the ideal loving family they never had. When this (usually) doesn't materialize per courtship dreams and hopes, adults and kids need to...

• affirm their stepfamily identity and accept what it means;

• accept that they can attain real benefits from stepfamily membership, but probably not all that they had hoped for (a significant loss), and...

• grieve their lost hopes expectations, and many other things.

      As co-parents work at these things, they can help kids and other family adults build realistic relationship expectations - i.e. they can all grow some bonding, respect, and friendship together over time, and avoid disappointment, hurt, and frustration from expecting (idealized) biofamily-like love.

"No, Melissa, you don't have to love your stepsister (or stepparent or step-grandparent), and she doesn't have to love you. You two can enjoy becoming friends and stepsisters, over time.")

      When real stepfamily bonds and love do grow over some years, they're a priceless bonus! For more perspective, see this article on stepparent-stepchild love.

top